I'm going with ENTP for Trey and INTP for Matt. Trey seems more energetic, while Matt seems more passive.
Why xNTP? Well, xNTPs tend to criticize by making fun of everything (while xNTJs criticize with a sarcastic aura). Regardless, NTs seem to know no limits to political correctness, which is probably why NTs make the best satirists -- i.e. Mark Twain, Jane Austin, Kevin Smith, or Dave Barry.