SuperFob
New member
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2008
- Messages
- 264
- MBTI Type
- INFJ
The ISFJ possibility could also be explained if there were something in the circumstances of Hermione's environment, something in the circumstances of her upbringing, or something in the circumstances of her life at Hogwarts that would've brought out the T side of her personality more than normal. I'm not saying that I can name any such circumstances. They probably don't even exist. I just feel like pointing out there's so many tiny little nuances and ways of looking at Hermione that any one of them could explain why she might in fact be ISFJ who displays more T-like tendencies than the typical ISFJ would. I don't think there's ever an end to the possibilities that can be used in explaining something about someone's type.The only way I can see of ISFJ as being a possibility is if we say that what looks like stereotypical Te behavior is actually Fe, or motivated by Fe.
So, while I agree that ISTJ is more likely, I think that there's so many ways that we could look at Hermione that we can't ever truly rule out the possiblity of her being something else.
A person's type is never, ever completely certain. I stand by that.