Ahh, I am witnessing a classic error of test scoring!
I got The Girl Next Door.
Cute, neither Dark nor Light, and neither Artsy nor Stylish. This sounds like a blah category, right? Oh, my, no. The Girl Next Door has been the subject of more dirty fantasies than you could possibly count. She's so sweet, and innocent, and infinitely corruptible. Every morning you glance out your window hoping she'll have forgotten to draw the blinds. You may feel bad about it, but you know you'll be doing it again tomorrow.
But I don't think that's right at all. I think that's quite far from the truth. What I believe happened here is that I answers with such equality on my attraction to dark and light, as well as artsy and stylish (I think that's a bunk dichotomy, by the way), that it just assumed I want something in the middle. But actually, I find something in the middle much less attractive then the extremes of either category.
Just because someone likes two different poles equally does not mean they have the highest preference for what is inbetween.