This is a MBTI vs socionics question, that of "which makes the most sense in profiling" and "which makes the most sense applying function to type." So once again you get a chance to prove your point.
Scroll down to the quoted.
I've made this question easier for you to analyze because I wrote out logical sentences and gave an example for each. We all know that P is information gathering and J is decision making. Reminder that these aren't full type-descriptions, but they simply describe function role of that type. (the same description can also be of other types, ie ENTP description can be of ENFP or ESFP)
So the two questions are in bold and the descriptions below to analyze are in italics, because we must question if the IxxP is primary P or primary J, and same with IxxJ.
Regards to primary J function
This is ENTJ no?
Pi supporting Je
fitting personal information (Pi) into a well known system (Je); matching up a current system (Je) with a possible or previous event (Pi) ie. this is true because it makes sense to "me"
is the following describing INTP or INTJ?
Pe supporting Ji
fitting outside information (Pe) into a personal opinion (Ji); matching up a current event (Pe) with with a possible idea or personal opinion (Ji) ie. that info is correct because it matches "my opinion"
Regards to primary P function
is the following description of INTJ or INTP?
Je supporting Pi
reflecting personal information (Pi) upon a well known system; (Je) matching up a current system (Je) with a possible or previous event (Pi - in this I am assuming E is circumstantial) ie. that idea reminds me of when this happened
and then ENTP
Ji supporting Pe
reflecting outside information (Pe) upon a personal opinion (Ji); matching up a current event (Pe) with with a possible idea or personal opinion (Ji) ie. this event reminds me of this idea or philosophy
I'm assuming I'm correct in simplifying these function roles so this question should be easy, unless I've made a mistake in theory, in which I'd love for you to correct me.
By taking a vote of which italicized description belongs to which type and then explaining why you think this, we can end unneeded reference to the wrong. So vote and explain, and don't contradict yourself!