• You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to additional post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), view blogs, respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free, so please join our community today! Just click here to register. You should turn your Ad Blocker off for this site or certain features may not work properly. If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us by clicking here.

Need for and fear of closeness at the same time

Moiety

New member
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
5,996
MBTI Type
ISFJ
hommefatal said:
It's just that people are scared of me because I'm uberhonest. I always tell people what my goal is.

Honesty will take you nowhere if you have a black heart. Hitler was lunatic and pretty honest too.

hommefatal said:
No. I just want to say lunatic behaviour is more of a challenge and thus more interesting.

Well if it's a challenge AND it only brings you trouble, then you might want to reconsider. Unless you don't want closeness with someone, after all.

ooooh...watch out kids!
ahhh1gv.gif

Why aren't the mods keeping these loons in check?
 

hommefatal

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
938
Honesty will take you nowhere if you have a black heart. Hitler was lunatic and pretty honest too.



Well if it's a challenge AND it only brings you trouble, then you might want to reconsider. Unless you don't want closeness with someone, after all.



Why aren't the mods keeping these loons in check?
Yes. It's pretty depressing. I am not a lunatic at all. I hate violence and bad thoughts. I just don't want to act, eat, sleep, fuck, etc. like everyone. Is that so much of a problem?
I don't want to meet any lunatics. I just want to play.
Thoughts shouldn't be censored if they're overly abstract.
 

sculpting

New member
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
4,148
personal criticism, loneliness, obligations

I fear not to be accepted.

Okay, but let me ask you - what's so great about being accepted?
.

I think the down side of being Ne dom is that you rely on other's impressions of you to serve as a mirror to help define you. We sit in the middle of a web and seek feedback from the external world to help us remember that we are still here.

For Fi this is emo feedback on some level. We seek acceptance of our emotions from the external world. Even if you are in a close relationship, but do not feel "safe" or open with that person, you may not feel that you are getting emotional affirmation/acceptance from them. So you want to be close but you push them away as you do not feel safe letting them inside of your walls. They may hurt you by rejecting your emotions which is very painful.

You are still young-15 right?-so I could totally see this being a part of growing up. Stypg is right on some level. If you build your own sense of confidence in yourself-develop your Fi, values, define yourself by your own internal standards rather than looking for external emo affirmation or support-it makes you much more resiliant.

You bring your true self to a relationship.

(not that I do this myself...) :hug:
 

hommefatal

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
938
I am confident of myself but it's bad when people don't talk to you because you don't adapt to conventions.
 

King sns

New member
Joined
Nov 4, 2008
Messages
6,714
MBTI Type
enfp
Enneagram
6w7
Instinctual Variant
sp/sx
That's a major symptom of Borderline.

It suits me very well. I always think "I'm so alone, I need a partner" but when I meet someone I fear they could hate me.

Hmm..
It is not reccommended to psychiatrists to diagnose borderline before say early 20's. Some symptoms of borderline personality can be mistaken for just growing and teenagerhood. Wait a few years.
 

hommefatal

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
938
Hmm..
It is not reccommended to psychiatrists to diagnose borderline before say early 20's. Some symptoms of borderline personality are just a part of growing and teenagerhood. Wait a few years.
I didn't feel like recognising Borderline. The test I've taken said:
Histrionic: Moderate
Dependent: Moderate
Narcisstic: Moderate
The others were low. I definitely don't suffer from a personality disorder. Would I be able to post here then?
 

Moiety

New member
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
5,996
MBTI Type
ISFJ
Yes. It's pretty depressing. I am not a lunatic at all. I hate violence and bad thoughts. I just don't want to act, eat, sleep, fuck, etc. like everyone. Is that so much of a problem?
I don't want to meet any lunatics. I just want to play.
Thoughts shouldn't be censored if they're overly abstract.

You said you were a lunatic thought, back there. And maybe you need to learn to be a little humble to see that other people might think just like you more often than you realize.
 

hommefatal

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
938
You said you were a lunatic thought, back there. And maybe you need to learn to be a little humble to see that other people might think just like you more often than you realize.
Yeah, I am one of those leftist hypocrites. If they talked to me it would be fine by me. But once I'm famous everyone will love me.
 

hommefatal

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
938
It will never happen by force. You are writing me a license to behave any way I please. My excuse is self-defense. But I have not really exploited it, have I?

People have to earn my respect. They can also unearn it.

If you want my cooperation and respect, be nice. So far I've not seen any lasting sign of that.

Think of the opposition. Are they nice or nasty? How can you earn their respect and cooperation? It's almost impossible for any sustained length of time because they want to win. I am not competing to win. Therefore it is possible to earn my respect and cooperation for a sustained period of time.
Yeah, okay. I just felt deeply hurted by criticism so I tried to defend myself. I am very cooperative.
 

Gewitter27

New member
Joined
Jun 19, 2009
Messages
651
MBTI Type
INTP
Enneagram
5w4
I pretty much meet the BL criteria, except for the Black and White thinking that defines it.
 

mortabunt

Permabanned
Joined
Apr 10, 2009
Messages
963
MBTI Type
type
Enneagram
5
It suits me very well. I always think "I'm so alone, I need a partner" but when I meet someone I fear they could hate me.

I have the same problem, however, I usually am right about them gettign to hate me.
 

Fidelia

Iron Maiden
Staff member
Joined
May 31, 2009
Messages
14,497
MBTI Type
INFJ
A partner isn't going to make you feel not alone in the long term.

These feelings hommefatal, won't go away all at once, simply because it takes time to develop confidence and a sense of who you are. I think most of us at 15 were not quite comfortable with ourselves. One way of dealing with that is trying on different personas and different ways of dressing to see if they fit and feel comfortable. Most people do that in some way or another.

Your "acting like a lunatic" I think is one way of trying on a different persona. In this case, it is a particularly obnoxious one that people sometimes don't react well to. The pity is that people never actually get to meet you, which you are not sure that they'll like. If you act loud and a little offensive, then it is not nearly so devastating if they don't like you, because it's not really you.

You also have a real need to be unique. The rest of us all want to be appreciated for what makes us different from other people. However, there are ways to go about it which alienate others, and ways that will bring others closer to us. It looks to me that if given the choice, for you negative attention (even if it hurts you) is much better than no attention at all.

The biggest two keys dealing with the uncomfortable and frightening feelings you mentioned are these: first of all, you need a close emotional connection to someone that will love you unconditionally. If you don't have this at home, you need to find it in the form of a teacher, someone at a church, or a caring adult in the community. Although people your own age aren't bad, they are going through the same struggles as you are and do not have abililty at this time to give you the attention and love that you need in a healthy way. When your brain is less busy trying to find a strong attachment to someone, it is will start helping you develop emotionally. There is a bunch more that could be said about this, but I will save for another post. Secondly, you need to develop a sense of identity and confidence based on actual skills as well as character qualities that you develop. In every conversation and with every person you meet, there is something that you can learn from them. Even people who do things negatively are opportunities to learn how you don't want to go about it. Start reaching out to the people that you meet. Ask them questions. Build on the things that you are already good at. Volunteer. Teach other people any skills you have and keep acquiring new ones. Think of ways that you could show appreciation or help for others. You will find that people start responding differently to you and you will also have confidence from knowing that you know how to do something well and have something to offer others. There is only a need to act crazy and unconventional (and offensive) when you don't feel like you have a legitimate identity to show to those that you meet. I think there is an interesting and talented person in you that others rarely get to look at when they meet you. Find him!!
 

MonkeyGrass

New member
Joined
Jun 13, 2009
Messages
877
MBTI Type
infj
Enneagram
7
fidelia- +1!

hommefatal- I'm hearing less what sounds like borderline, and more an intelligent teenager (with a penchant for the bizarre) who's trying to find their unique place in life.

Borderliners (and I've attracted more than a couple) tend to obsess over a certain person who makes them feel safe and admired, and then BLOW and hate you when you're not the perfectly reciprocating being they'd envisioned. And they're incapable of ever stepping out of that, nearly, and often never realize they do it.

The fact that you're concerned about it at such a young age makes me think you may be fascinated by the idea of being borderline, and that you have a(n undeveloped) knack for recognizing emotional/relational patterns. If you're like most abstract thinking people, you'll likely try on several different "skins" before you find the one that suits you best.

I think Fidelia is right, there's a very bright, unique young man in you. The more confident you grow, the more you'll be able to pick him out in a lineup and say, "That's ME." It will get easier to separate yourself from all the other observations you're picking up on, promise. :O)
 

lorkan

New member
Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Messages
260
MBTI Type
INFJ
I have had exactly the same problem and I actually feel It's coming up every now and then. As a pretending psychiatrist; isn't this a sign of repressed rage/anger? (I'm refering to the attitude of not wanting to be "normal")
 

Snow Turtle

New member
Joined
May 28, 2007
Messages
1,335
Fear of rejection is quite a common FJ trait. The idea of not wanting to be normal can also be linked to fear of rejection, if you adopt the belief that nobody is going to be interested in normal people. I need to be unique and special for people to recognise me and therefore loved.
 

lorkan

New member
Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Messages
260
MBTI Type
INFJ
Im not so sure if ISFJ's and INFJ's have the same reason for the dislike of being normal. Personally I really don't have any problem of actually being normal or living a normal life. BUT, there are 2 things that scares the shit out of me. And it is, 1; the inflexibility it brings with having chidlren, wife, house with taxes etc, not being able any more to control the direction of your life (fear of living for others in a traditional way), 2; having to act normal (sensibel) yet still feel inside that it is totally against what I want my life to be, having an appearance to others that I am in control while feeling like a freak inside just makes me crazy and feel like a liar. I ALWAYS have unconventional thoughts, always thinking almost directly opposed to what you are suppose to think when you live a normal life.

Im not afraid feeling that other people might get bored of me. If they do get bored of me I just figure that we probably have different life rythms, and that's the end of that. Not to get hung up
 

Snow Turtle

New member
Joined
May 28, 2007
Messages
1,335
Im not so sure if ISFJ's and INFJ's have the same reason for the dislike of being normal. Personally I really don't have any problem of actually being normal or living a normal life. BUT, there are 2 things that scares the shit out of me. And it is, 1; the inflexibility it brings with having chidlren, wife, house with taxes etc, not being able any more to control the direction of your life (fear of living for others in a traditional way), 2; having to act normal (sensibel) yet still feel inside that it is totally against what I want my life to be, having an appearance to others that I am in control while feeling like a freak inside just makes me crazy and feel like a liar. I ALWAYS have unconventional thoughts, always thinking almost directly opposed to what you are suppose to think when you live a normal life.

Im not afraid feeling that other people might get bored of me. If they do get bored of me I just figure that we probably have different life rythms, and that's the end of that. Not to get hung up

Overall I doubt there is a strong correlation between type and reason for not wanting to be normal. I've only given one of the reasons, my reason, that a person may dislike being normal. But Yes~ I don't really identify so much with those feelings since from my perspective it's possible to be normal and authentic at the same time. I'm probably naive but most individuals I met aren't really normal when I get to know them on a deeper level. This whole idea of a norm based on perception of social mass can sometimes be a little pointless. It reminds me of how I can generalise and dislike large groups of people, but when I meet them on an individual level it's as if it's no longer there. *shrugs*
 

Fidelia

Iron Maiden
Staff member
Joined
May 31, 2009
Messages
14,497
MBTI Type
INFJ
I agree that people need to find a balance between authenticity and being in control of themselves. However, in the case of hommefatale, I almost feel that he is referring to behaviour that is meant to shock/get a reaction from others. That, I feel, is actually not authentic and feels a little forced. It also is not working well for him because he feels rejected a lot of the time and yet does not want to change what he is doing. He wants people to accept him unconditionally. Perhaps after people come to love him, they can do that, but as a first impression or a casual acquaintance, they can't and won't appreciate him for that.

In your case Lorkin, you might choose to have an unconventional life that may not include a wife, kids, and taxes and that's just fine. As for having strange thoughts etc, the fact is no one expresses everything they are thinking to everyone they meet all the time. There is nothing wrong with expressing your thoughts and being who you are. However, you may only do that with a select group of people. We all behave somewhat differently according to what a situation calls for.

If I prefer to wear jeans, it doesn't necessarily mean that I'm being inauthentic when I arrive at a wedding appropriately dressed. It would be self-centred and rude of me to dress for comfort on an occasion like that, even if I didn't care what people thought about my attire for my own sake. It would imply a lack of respect for the people getting married and the seriousness of the occasion, so for their sake, I dress up. I think that social behaviour is similar. No one is saying that you have to make a situation where you are socially "dressed up" all the time your main milieu, but there are times when it implies a lack of respect and consideration if you don't make an effort to put others at ease and do what is appropriate for that situation.
 

Snow Turtle

New member
Joined
May 28, 2007
Messages
1,335
How do you know what he is thinking? Can you read his mind? Is the information second hand? Did someone tell you what he is thinking? If so, did that person interpret what they heard correctly? Did you correctly interpret that persons interpretation? Did he tell you what he was thinking? Did you correctly interpret what he told you?

Seems to me you might be thinking too much.

The conclusion was drawn from the original post. There was nothing in Fidelia's post that indicates huge assumptions or attempts at mind reading. From my perspective Fidelia is merely commenting on the fact that it's fine to lead or have unconventional lifestyles/thoughts. She is challenging the original belief put forward that society rejects people, that it's not fine to express these feelings and that a mask must be put on. Ultimately there is no problem of being inauthentic, if there is no need to hide in the first place because society does not demand it. She is claiming that most people don't reveal their inner thoughts, and that individuals shown unusual parts of themselves depending on their situation. I'd further add that it's possible the idea of normal behaviour may just be an illusion.

This is supported by the fact that most individuals consider themselves unique and being slightly unconventional. Group behaviour tends to be extremely different to individual behaviour - People's perceptions of normal tend to be based on social masses.
 
Top