[Type 8] Are Js more "8" than Ps?

[yenom]

Claim: Js are more eight than Ps.
Evidence:?

 

[entropie]

Wearing no pants atm, that's no good authority figure

 

[EcK]

Wearing no pants atm, that's no good authority figure

except if u work in the porn industry

 

[entropie]

 

[wildcat]

For those who thinks Js are more 8 than Ps, what evidence do you have to support this?

It is simple.
The dichotomy of E is about drive and control.
P = drive > control
J = control > drive.

The dichotomy of D and C takes place simultaneously with the dichotomy of P and J.
The dichotomy of E and I is simply the axis reversed.
It is not another axis.

 

[yenom]

 

[Jaguar]

Personal experience does not justify anything. Please answer the question.

I have an opinion X. Please provide me evidence to the contrary, preferably by leading experts in the field, appended with a 200-page detailed summary with proper references.

Unless these requirements are met, I hold my opinion X, and X is true.

HAHAHAHA.

 

[proteanmix]

Personal experience does not justify anything. Please answer the question.

Considering that the ONLY evidence for most of the BS that is said on this forum is personal experience and anecdotes this is a very statement.

 

[the state i am in]

claims without evidence to support is simply not true right?
so you say the earth is the center of the universe, yet you lack evidence to back it up other than the fact that the it appears to be so in the night sky.
Does that make your statement true?

estj 8?

your epistemological approach needs work.

 

[yenom]

estj 8?

your epistemological approach needs work.

What evidence is this. I could say the same thing about ESTP eight?


Judger
Makes life firm and controlled
Easier to finish projects
Organized
More serious
Routinized and predictable
Uses schedules and timetables as a guide
Dislikes suprises and needs advanced warnings
Needs issues settled
Hard-working Leisurely
Can be too close-minded Gets things done as soon as possible
"Goes down with the ship"

Perceiver
Adapts to situations, and gathers more information before deciding
Makes life flexible and relaxed
Prefers to start projects
Disorganized
More carefree
Spontaneous and unpredictable
Does whatever comes up
Enjoys surprises and spontaneous happenings
Doesn't like anything unalteratable
Leisurely
Can be too open-minded and fickle
Procrastinates
Can be overly responsible
Can be irresponsible
"Changes horses in midstream"


Here is a comparison chart, what makes Js more eight than percievers then?