[Traditional Enneagram] Enneatype theme song?

[Kierva]

Njósnavélin - Sigur Rós

Ni-INFp 9w1 sx/sp​

 

[Kierva]

Sky Fits Heaven - Madonna

Se/Ni XXXp 3w4/4w3/7w8 sx/so​

 

[Thunderbringer]

2w3 Sx/So

 

[Cloud of Thunder]

What makes you say that would be a type 1 song? 2w1 sx/sp (or sp/sx) seems to make more sense to me, but my grasp of the enneagram is often flawed so I'm curious as to your reasoning.

Following your link, then putting the actual URL in the video tag seemed to fix it...

There's a lot of jealousy and self-loathing in that song, which unhealthy 1s are full of.

 

[TenebrousReflection]

There's a lot of jealousy and self-loathing in that song, which unhealthy 1s are full of.

I can see some jealousy but not self loathing (not a lot of blaming the self for the predicament she is singing about - "am I that unimportant" & "am I so insignificant" come across to me as acusatory rather than self critical), but the overall vibe I got was self pity, bitterness/resentment, abandonment (or betrayal) and feeling unloved - which to me seems to fit pretty well with average to below average health 2s (I could see 6s as well since abandonment/betrayal is a key theme I hear in the song).

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Type 2

 

[Elfboy]

6w7 Sx/So

 

[Speed Gavroche]

6w7 Sx/So

Yes! And theses one:

Prety much the entire album actually.

 

[Speed Gavroche]

Type 3

 

[Elfboy]

Type 2

2w1 Social

 

[Elfboy]

There's a lot of jealousy and self-loathing in that song, which unhealthy 1s are full of.

it's also present in unhealthy
- 2s
- 3s
- 4s

 

[Kierva]

Unravel - Björk

Fe-INFp/Ni-ENFj 4w3 sx/sp​

 

[Kierva]

Eyes Wide Open - Gotye

Fe-ENFj 7w6 so/sp​

 

[Thunderbringer]

4w5 so/sx

 

[EJCC]

I'm not sure if this is type 1 or not, but both my type 1 roommate and I relate to this song on a gut level, at our darkest moments:
[YOUTUBE="rc1dw8MHriA"]Type 1[/YOUTUBE]
This one too (in my case, since I haven't talked to my roommate and therefore can't speak for her):
[YOUTUBE="8q182kWAhiM"]Type 1w2[/YOUTUBE]
And this seems pretty 2w1, to me:
[YOUTUBE="IG4N-vVHLA4"]Type 2w1[/YOUTUBE]

 

[Thunderbringer]

1w2 sx/sp

 

[Grace]

This was song that a 2 put on a CD for me (I'm a 9):

Song for a 9

[YOUTUBE="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WI_9czYEY4s"][/YOUTUBE]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WI_9czYEY4s

 

[Grace]

Let me try again, song for a 9:

 

[Grace]

Here is another good one for a 9:

 

[Trunks]

I don't know whether this is for type 6, 3 or 9