Metal. Is it music?

[sonictard]

But that isn't what this thread is about.

Metal is music anyway, since any kind of arranged sounds into patterns is considered music.

'Arranged sounds into patterns'- that's your experience of music. Sorry lady, but that seem as some kind of robotic thinking. Maybe you are young, maybe you are bombarded by media and internet, but that's not the holy grail of music. Music is singing of your soul, language of your heart, broken, shattered, or cured, whatever.

 

[Null]

'Arranged sounds into patterns'- that's your experience of music. Sorry lady, but that seem as some kind of robotic thinking. Maybe you are young, maybe you are bombarded by media and internet, but that's not the holy grail of music. Music is singing of your soul, language of your heart, broken, shattered, or cured, whatever.

I'm soulless.

 

[Hive]

'Arranged sounds into patterns'- that's your experience of music. Sorry lady, but that seem as some kind of robotic thinking. Maybe you are young, maybe you are bombarded by media and internet, but that's not the holy grail of music. Music is singing of your soul, language of your heart, broken, shattered, or cured, whatever.

"Arranged sounds into patterns" is actually a pretty decent definition of what music is. It's funny how you invalidate it because it's "her experience of music" (when it actually reads more as an attempt at defining what music is), and then counter it with a definition that is wholly subjective and only reflects your own, personal relationship with music. There's plenty of mass produced music devoid of sincerity and soul that wouldn't fit your definition, lol.

You're the one with a narrow perspective here, bro.

 

[sonictard]

I'm soulless.

No, you are young.

"Arranged sounds into patterns" is actually a pretty decent definition of what music is. It's funny how you invalidate it because it's "her experience of music" (when it actually reads more as an attempt at defining what music is), and then counter it with a definition that is wholly subjective and only reflects your own, personal relationship with music. There's plenty of mass produced music devoid of sincerity and soul that wouldn't fit your definition, lol.

You're the one with a narrow perspective here, bro.

Ok.

 

[Null]

No, you are young.

One doesn't exclude the other.

 

[sonictard]

"Arranged sounds into patterns" is actually a pretty decent definition of what music is. It's funny how you invalidate it because it's "her experience of music" (when it actually reads more as an attempt at defining what music is), and then counter it with a definition that is wholly subjective and only reflects your own, personal relationship with music. There's plenty of mass produced music devoid of sincerity and soul that wouldn't fit your definition, lol.

You're the one with a narrow perspective here, bro.

You cannot define music, its stupid. And, please, stop pretending to be a gentlemen (Null), just be honest. I understand your urge to protect tender sex, but, your urge are not suppossed to be your real intention here.

One doesn't exclude the other.

Cheap compensation but, as I said - you are young.

 

[Hive]

You cannot define music, its stupid.

It can be done, but it'd be defined in such broad terms that it'd almost be redundant to do so. Yet, you tried.

 

[Null]

I understand your urge to protect tender sex,

What was this about?

 

[sonictard]

It can be done, but it'd be defined in such broad terms that it'd almost be redundant to do so. Yet, you tried.

Why define music? Music is the definition per se

 

[sonictard]

What was this about?

About tender sex

 

[Null]

About tender sex

Oh, thanks. I almost forgot.

 

[sonictard]

Oh, thanks. I almost forgot.

forgetful by the whim, typical feminine feigned intractability

 

[Null]

forgetful by the whim, typical feminine feigned intractability

Let's be friends, we're both alphas in the end.

Metal is music, metal is awesome, metal speaks me out of the heart.

 

[sonictard]

Let's be friends, we're both alphas in the end.

Metal is music, metal is awesome, metal speaks me out of the heart.

Friends, of course

Im not an Alpha, just teasing you...in the end

<3

 

[Null]

Friends, of course

Im not an Alpha, just teasing you...in the end

<3

That's not what I meant with alpha, but okay. <3

 

[Mole]

Ramstein and Metal

I rather like Ramstein. Of course I recognise they play to a nostalgia for military masculininity, so they might be considered camp. But I confess a weakness for them, click on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3q8Od5qJio

 

[/DG/]

Why the hell is this thread still going after three years?

 

[Duffy]

I rather like Ramstein. Of course I recognise they play to a nostalgia for military masculininity, so they might be considered camp. But I confess a weakness for them, click on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3q8Od5qJio

I forgot about these guys. I used to listen to some of their songs.

Why the hell is this thread still going after three years?

Troll-like responses and troll-like threads get a lot of responses. It's an attraction to drama and controversy. Besides, it difficult to have discussion involving agreement.

 

[Fun in the Sun]

 

[Forever]

That's not what I meant with alpha, but okay. <3

Alpha positive right?